asked 17.3k views
5 votes
3. Why do you think Magellan had problems with the crews of his ships?

2 Answers

4 votes
Ferdinand began to encounter some problems, word had got out that Ferdinand was Portuguese of origin. Several of the Spanish captains didn't trust Ferdinand and were said to have plotted to murder Ferdinand. The news spread quickly and chaos began to breakout among the crew.
Some ruthless members of the crew attempted to murder Ferdinand, despite failing these cold-hearted men were executed
4 votes

Answer:Ferdinand Magellan, the Portuguese explorer who led the first expedition to circumnavigate the globe from 1519 to 1522, faced several challenges with the crews of his ships during the voyage. These problems can be attributed to a combination of factors:

Long Duration: The expedition was an incredibly ambitious undertaking for its time, and it lasted for several years. The crew members were away from their homes and loved ones for an extended period, which could lead to homesickness, discontent, and morale issues.

Harsh Conditions: The voyage was grueling and subjected the crew to harsh conditions, including storms, rough seas, and limited food and water supplies. These hardships took a physical and emotional toll on the crew, leading to dissatisfaction.

Cultural Differences: Magellan's fleet was multinational, with crew members from different countries, including Spain and Portugal. Cultural and linguistic differences could have led to conflicts and misunderstandings among the crew.

Leadership Style: Magellan's leadership style was often authoritarian, and he faced resistance and mutiny attempts from some of his officers and crew members who disagreed with his decisions. His strict discipline and refusal to tolerate dissent contributed to crew discontent.

Scarcity of Supplies: The expedition faced challenges in securing provisions and supplies along the way, especially in the Pacific Ocean. This scarcity of necessities like food and fresh water added to the crew's grievances.

Unfamiliar Territory: The crew was venturing into largely uncharted waters, and the fear of the unknown could have heightened tensions and anxiety among the sailors.

Loyalty and Trust: Trust and loyalty among the crew were critical for the success of the expedition. However, some crew members may not have fully trusted Magellan's leadership or his intentions, which could have contributed to problems.

Despite these challenges, Magellan and his expedition managed to accomplish their historic feat, circumnavigating the globe, albeit with a significantly reduced crew and resources by the time they returned to Spain. Magellan himself did not survive the entire journey, as he was killed in the Philippines in 1521 during a skirmish with local inhabitants. The expedition's successful completion remains a testament to the determination and endurance of the crew, despite the many difficulties they faced along the way.

answered
User Basem
by
8.9k points
Welcome to Qamnty — a place to ask, share, and grow together. Join our community and get real answers from real people.