Final answer:
To determine the best retirement plan option, calculate the present value of each alternative at different interest rates. At 0% interest, both alternatives have the same present value. At 8% interest, choose the $350,000 received after 5 years, and at 20% interest, also choose the $350,000 received after 5 years.
Step-by-step explanation:
To determine which alternative to choose for retirement, we need to calculate the present value of each option at different interest rates. The present value is the current worth of a future cash flow.
If the interest rate is 0% per year, both alternatives have the same present value. At an interest rate of 8% per year, the present value of $250,000 is $154,338.41, while the present value of $350,000 received after 5 years is $223,763.66. Lastly, at an interest rate of 20% per year, the present value of $250,000 is $64,516.13, while the present value of $350,000 received after 5 years is $183,467.36.
Based on these calculations, the alternative to choose will depend on the interest rate:
If the interest rate is 0% per year, it doesn't matter which alternative you choose, as they have the same present value.
If the interest rate is 8% per year, it is better to choose the $350,000 received after 5 years, as it has a higher present value.
If the interest rate is 20% per year, it is better to choose the $350,000 received after 5 years, as it has a higher present value.