Possible responses to Herrick's claims could include questioning the evidence, challenging assumptions, or considering the broader context.
An opponent could offer a few possible responses to Herrick. For example, they might argue that Herrick's claims are based on limited evidence and therefore lack credibility. Another response could be to challenge Herrick's assumptions or to provide alternative explanations for the evidence presented. A third possible response could be to question the relevance or significance of Herrick's claims in the broader context of the topic.