Question

.

Which of the following would be the most effective feedback to give in a peer review?

“Your paper isn’t very interesting. You should make it more interesting.”

“Your paper reads quickly, but you might consider adding more details to make it more interesting.”

“Your paper is too short.”

“I don’t like the topic of your paper.”

Answer 1

B would be the most appropriate and helpful response, because it identifies a problem, and offers a solution. This is a great example of constructive criticism.