Question

Whose depiction of Macbeth—Shakespeare’s or Holinshed’s—is more interesting or compelling from a reader’s standpoint? Why?

Answer 1

I think its Shakespeare's version of Macbeth. In Shakespeare's  version,  you can see the mask that Macbeth wears. Many people can see him as a good person in this version, you can also see how he is when he is consumed by paranoia and greed for power.