The correct answers are C and D. 
University athletic director resigns amid controversy 
 Softball league umpire admits error on final play
A is incorrect because it states an opinion on how the Quarterback looked, not a fact that they were lazy. 
In B, "Stunning Upset" implies the writer wanted things to go the other way. 
C and D state facts, not opinions and are not emotional. 
"Fall from Grace" is subjective because it means the writer believed they were in good graces before the fall, a more objective headline here would be something like, "Controversy Continues to Surround Ice Skating Champion"