Question

Is an eye for an eye a good basis for determining an appropriate punishment why or why not

Please write 4 sentences

Answer 1

No

Step-by-step explanation:

From the perspective of modern criminal law, a punishment has multiple purposes—not only to punish the criminal, but to help the victim recover from loss and protect the community from further harm. “An eye for an eye” punishment may sound like a fair punishment in the sense that the criminal suffers what the victim went through. However, it is not a good basis for determining a punishment because it focuses all its attention on getting revenge and fails to consider restitution and rehabilitation.

Answer 2

Answer: Yes.

Explanation: It is appropriate punishment because its fair for the other person if they both do wrong, although, it wouldn't be fair to another person if they did nothing wrong.