Question

All good football players are over 200 pounds. Earl is 230 pounds. Kaylie concludes Earl is a good football player. Is her conclusion valid? Explain.

Answer 1

I don't think so

Explanation:

If being over 200 lbs makes you a good football player, then Earl could be a good player. But you need to be skilled at football to be good at it. Your weight doesn't make you good at something. So in my opinion, I don't think Kaylie's conclusion is valid.

I hope this answer helped you