Answer: 
 has greater impact on the freezing point depression of ice.
Step-by-step explanation:
Depression in freezing point is given by: 
 
 = Depression in freezing point 
i= vant hoff factor 
 = freezing point constant 
m= molality 
 
a) i = 4 for 
 as it dissociates to give 4 ions in water.

b) i = 3 for 
 as it dissociates to give 3 ions in water.

As the vant hoff factor is higher for 
 , it has greater impact on the freezing point depression of ice.