Question

what does Thomas Paine say in response to the argument that the British have protected the colonlies?

Answer 1

It is argued that Britain has protected the colonies, but Paine points out that Britain protected the colonies for its own financial gain, not out of altruism. Additionally if the colonies had not been dependent on Britain, then they would no longer be enemies with countries that are enemies of Britain.

Answer 2

Paine says that such an argument fails to realize that America has evolved and no longer needs Britain's help