Question

Decide if the "personal a" is necessary in the following sentence. yo amo ____ david. the "personal a" is necessary. the "personal a" is not necessary.

Answer 1

The 'personal a' is necessary in the sentence 'yo amo ____ David' because David is a specific person and the object of affection, thus the correct sentence is 'yo amo a David'. The use of the 'personal a' differentiates between subject and object pronouns in Spanish.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the sentence 'yo amo ____ David', the "personal a" is necessary. In Spanish, when the direct object is a person or a pet, the "personal a" is used before the name or pronoun. Therefore, the sentence should read 'yo amo a David'.

Understanding the difference between subject personal pronouns and object personal pronouns is essential in using them correctly. Subject personal pronouns are used as the subject of a verb (who is doing the action), while object personal pronouns serve as the object (who is receiving the action).

Since David is the object of affection in the sentence (the one being loved), and he is a specific person, the personal a is used to indicate this relationship.

Answer 2

The 'personal a' is necessary for the sentence 'yo amo ____ David,' making the correct sentence 'yo amo a David.' The 'personal a' is used in Spanish before the name of a person who is the direct object of a verb, showing they are receiving the action directly.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the sentence 'yo amo ____ David', the personal a is indeed necessary. In Spanish, when the direct object is a person or a pet that's personalized, the personal a is used before the object person’s name. This rule helps to distinguish the subject from the object in a sentence and indicates that the object is a person who is receiving the action of the verb directly. In English, this would translate to 'I love David,' without the need for the personal 'a,' but in Spanish, it is grammatically correct to say 'yo amo a David' to indicate that David is the one who is loved.

Understanding the difference between subject personal pronouns and object personal pronouns helps in correct sentence construction. Subject pronouns like 'yo' (I), 'él' (he), and 'ella' (she) indicate who is performing the action, whereas object pronouns like 'mí' (me), 'lo' (him), and 'la' (her) receive the action. The use of the personal a is specifically a feature of Spanish grammar, where it precedes the direct object that is a person.