Question

Closely read the quote and scenario. Then answer the question that follows.

"Vigor of government is essential to the security of liberty."—Alexander Hamilton

Imagine you are a representative to a state legislature meeting, debating the proposed Constitution. You have just read this quote in a newspaper essay. Which of the following accurately describes how you would respond?

A If you were a Federalist, you would use the quote to support your argument that a stronger centralized government would better serve the country.
B If you were an Anti-Federalist, you would use the quote to support your argument that a weak confederation of sovereign states would lead to less abuse of power.
C If you were a Federalist, you would use the quote to support your argument that a bill of rights was necessary to safeguard against abuse of power.
D If you were an Anti-Federalist, you would use the quote to support your argument that only a pure democracy of local governments is the best government.

Answer 1

If you were a Federalist, you would use the quote to support your argument that a stronger centralized government would better serve the country.

Step-by-step explanation:

The Federalists were is support of a strong central government, they supported the new Constitution as is. The anti-Federalists wanted the Bill of Rights. So, the best choice for this answer is A, that if you were a Federalist, you would woud use the quote that a stronger centralized government would better serve the country.

Answer 2

A. If you were a Federalist, you would use the quote to support your argument that a stronger centralized government would better serve the country.

Step-by-step explanation:

Alexander Hamilton was one of the key advocates of the Federalist position, which was in favor of a strong centralized government. The quote from Hamilton emphasizes the need for a robust government structure to ensure the protection of liberty. Thus, as a Federalist, one would use this quote to argue that a strong centralized government is crucial to maintaining the liberties of the citizenry. This would contrast with the Anti-Federalist position, which favored a weaker central government and stronger state governments to avoid potential abuses of power at the federal level.