asked 13.6k views
5 votes
20 Points:

How many ways are there to form a 5 person committee from 2 freshmen, 3 sophomores, 2 juniors, and 2 seniors if there cannot be the same number of juniors and seniors? Note that people are distinct.

1 Answer

6 votes

Answer: 81

=================================================

Step-by-step explanation:

2 freshmen + 3 sophomores + 2 juniors + 2 seniors = 9 students total.

Let's consider the cases where we have the same number of juniors and seniors. We'll then take the complement of this to get the final answer.

  • Case A will look at having 1 of each junior and senior.
  • Case B will look at having 2 each of juniors and seniors.

-----------

Case A: There is 1 junior and 1 senior

There are 2 ways to pick a junior and 2 ways to pick a senior. That's 2*2 = 4 ways so far.

Then we have 9-4 = 5 students left to pick from (i.e. 2 freshmen+3 sophomores = 5 students left) and we have 5-2 = 3 seats to fill. Order doesn't matter on the committee since each person has equal rank.

We use the nCr combination formula.

n = 5 students

r = 3 seats to fill

n C r = (n!)/(r!(n-r)!)

5 C 3 = (5!)/(3!*(5-3)!)

5 C 3 = (5!)/(3!*2!)

5 C 3 = (5*4*3!)/(3!*2!)

5 C 3 = (5*4)/(2!)

5 C 3 = (5*4)/(2*1)

5 C 3 = (20)/(2)

5 C 3 = 10

There are 10 ways to fill the remaining 3 seats when we pick from the freshmen and sophomores only.

To recap everything so far:

  • 4 ways to pick the 1 junior and 1 senior
  • 10 ways to pick the 3 other students (freshmen + sophomores)

Therefore, we have 4*10 = 40 different combinations possible for case A. We'll refer to this value later.

-----------

Case B: We pick 2 juniors and 2 seniors

Since there 2 juniors to pick from, and 2 junior seats to fill, there's only 1 way to do this. Likewise, there's only 1 way to pick the 2 seniors to fill the 2 seats.

In total so far there is 1*1 = 1 way to pick the 2 juniors and 2 seniors in any order you like.

Then we have 9-4 = 5 students left that are freshmen or sophomores. This is the number of choices we have for the final 5th seat.

We have 1*5 = 5 ways to have case B happen.

----------

Summary so far:

  • 40 ways to do case A
  • 5 ways to do case B
  • 40+5 = 45 ways to do either case.

There are 45 ways to have the same number of juniors as seniors (either 1 of each or 2 of each).

Now we must calculate the number of total combinations possible on this committee. We'll turn to the nCr formula again.

n = 9 students

r = 5 seats

n C r = (n!)/(r!(n-r)!)

9 C 5 = (9!)/(5!*(9-5)!)

9 C 5 = (9!)/(5!*4!)

9 C 5 = (9*8*7*6*5!)/(5!*4!)

9 C 5 = (9*8*7*6)/(4!)

9 C 5 = (9*8*7*6)/(4*3*2*1)

9 C 5 = (3024)/(24)

9 C 5 = 126

There are 126 different five-person committees possible.

Of those 126 committees, 45 of them consist of cases where we have the same number of juniors and seniors.

That must mean there are 126-45 = 81 combinations where we do not have the same number of juniors and seniors. This is where the concept of "complement" comes in.

answered
User Cas Bloem
by
7.6k points
Welcome to Qamnty — a place to ask, share, and grow together. Join our community and get real answers from real people.