asked 227k views
4 votes
Zach wants to run an experiment on reaction rates. He designs an experiment testing the reaction rate changes when magnesium and hydrochloric acid react.

He decides to run one trial with magnesium ribbon and 1.0 M HCl. For his second trial he rolls the magnesium ribbon into a tight coil and reacts it with 2.0 M HCl. In the third trial, Zach cuts the same amount of Magnesium into slivers and reacts them with 3.0 M HCl.

What is the problem with Zach's experimental design?
Responses

A Human error is uncontrolled.Human error is uncontrolled.

B There is no problem with his design.
There is no problem with his design.

C There are two variables in each trial.There are two variables in each trial.

D The concentration of the acid is too dilute.The concentration of the acid is too dilute.

asked
User Kpup
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Answer:

By isolating one variable at a time, Zach can draw more accurate conclusions about the relationship between the variable and the reaction rate. This helps to ensure that any observed changes are due to the variable being tested, rather than being influenced by other factors.

Step-by-step explanation:

The problem with Zach's experimental design is that there are two variables in each trial (option C).

In an experiment, it is important to have only one variable changing at a time in order to determine its specific effect on the outcome. This is known as controlling variables. In Zach's experiment, he is changing both the form of magnesium (ribbon, coil, slivers) and the concentration of the hydrochloric acid (1.0 M, 2.0 M, 3.0 M) in each trial. This means that it is unclear which variable is responsible for any observed changes in the reaction rate.

To improve the experimental design, Zach should only change one variable at a time while keeping all other conditions constant. For example, he could run separate trials where he keeps the magnesium form constant (e.g., ribbon) and changes only the concentration of the hydrochloric acid. This would allow him to observe and compare the effect of acid concentration on the reaction rate while controlling for other factors.

By isolating one variable at a time, Zach can draw more accurate conclusions about the relationship between the variable and the reaction rate. This helps to ensure that any observed changes are due to the variable being tested, rather than being influenced by other factors.

answered
User Yan Yankelevich
by
8.5k points
Welcome to Qamnty — a place to ask, share, and grow together. Join our community and get real answers from real people.