asked 121k views
2 votes
Within- and between-group variation (related to biological race)

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

The concept of within- and between-group variation with respect to human populations illustrates that genetic differences are greater within populations than between them, negating the biological concept of race. Studies support that traits vary along a spectrum and do not conform to racial categorizations. Ancestry, rather than race, is a more accurate descriptor for human genetic diversity.

Step-by-step explanation:

Understanding Within- and Between-Group Variation in Human Populations:

When examining human populations, researchers often refer to within-group and between-group variation to describe genetic differences. Within-group variation is the genetic variability that exists among individuals within a single population. Conversely, between-group variation represents the genetic differences observed between different populations. Studies, such as those conducted by Rosenberg et al., have shown that most genetic variation in humans occurs within populations rather than between them. These findings underline that the concept of biological race is scientifically problematic because genetic differences within any purported race are often as significant as, or more significant than, differences between races.

Biological anthropology and genetic studies indicate that human traits such as skin color, facial features, and blood type vary along a continuum rather than fitting neatly into racial categories. This continuous spectrum of variation within humans negates the utility of race as a biological concept. For instance, skin color ranges across a wide spectrum, and only a minute fraction of our DNA markers determine these visible characteristics. Social constructions of race, albeit lacking in biological validity, maintain a strong influence in many societies, affecting aspects such as discrimination and socio-economic conditions.

Ultimately, the concept of race is not supported by biological evidence, as the genetic differences within populations are too great. Instead, concepts like ancestry, which acknowledge the complex migrations and mixtures of human populations, are suggested as more accurate and useful for understanding human genetic diversity. Anthropologists and scientists encourage the shift away from racial categorization to a greater emphasis on genetic variation and shared humanity.

answered
User SeniorJD
by
7.9k points

No related questions found

Welcome to Qamnty — a place to ask, share, and grow together. Join our community and get real answers from real people.