Final answer:
The correct word to complete the sentence by indicating the need for two more players is 'friends'.
Step-by-step explanation:
The appropriate response to the sentence "If you need two more players for the softball game on Saturday, don't forget about my other __ and me." should fill the blank with the word friends because 'friends' indicates more than one person, which fits the context as two more players are needed. Therefore, the correct answer is option C. Friends.