asked 204k views
3 votes
What might be Mr. Manaby’s real reason for not allowing anyone to stay in the building past 5:00 pm? What is this foreshadowing?

the story is called sonata for harp and bicylce

asked
User Monocle
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

Mr. Manaby's rule of not allowing anyone to stay past 5:00 pm in 'Sonata for Harp and Bicycle' likely serves as a protective measure, with foreshadowing suggesting that breaking this rule could result in supernatural or eerie events, symbolic of a boundary between day and night.

Step-by-step explanation:

The student is asking about Mr. Manaby's real reason for enforcing a 5:00 pm curfew in the building in the story 'Sonata for Harp and Bicycle'. The descriptions from the passages provided suggest a world that contrasts significantly between day and night, hinting at underlying themes of secrecy and alienation. It could be foreshadowing a significant event or reveal that may occur after hours, possibly a supernatural or eerie turn of events that is a well-kept secret among those who know the true nature of the building.

It may also reflect on the characters' experiences and feelings of isolation from the normal, bustling daytime world. References to silence, solitude, and darkness in the narrations signify that Mr. Manaby's rule might be a protective measure.

The emptiness and stillness of night contrasted with the life of daytime settings symbolize a boundary between two different realities.

The foreshadowing indicates that breaking the curfew could lead to unexpected consequences, heightening the story's suspense and the reader's curiosity about the mysterious reasons behind Mr. Manaby's rule.